
With the trade deadline coming and going, the Blue Jackets traded away the biggest 1st round draft pick bust in their short history; Alex Picard. I don’t know Alex, but I’m sure he’s a good human being but he never panned out for the Blue Jackets as a great player they needed and expected.
In the 2004 Entry Draft the Blue Jackets held the 4th overall pick and pickings looked pretty slim as the first round featured very few impactful NHL-ers. For whatever reason, the Blue Jackets traded down with Carolina to the 8th pick. (***If anyone can find what this trade entailed I’m very curious***). Here’s a look at the first round of the draft:
1. Alexander Ovechkin LW – Washington Capitals
2. Evgeni Malkin C – Pittsburgh Penguins
3. Cam Barker D – Chicago Blackhawks
4. Andrew Ladd LW – Carolina Hurricanes*** (originally the Blue Jackets pick)
5. Blake Wheeler RW – Phoenix Coyotes
6. Al Montoya G – New York Rangers
7. Rostislav Olesz C – Florida Panthers
8. Alexandre Picard LW – Columbus Blue Jackets
9. Ladislav Smid D – Mighty Ducks of Anaheim (hahaha)
10. Boris Valabik D – Atlanta Thrashers
11. Lauri Tukonen RW – Los Angeles Kings
12. AJ Thelen D – Minnesota Wild
13. Drew Stafford RW – Buffalo Sabres
14. Devan Dubnyk G – Edmonton Oilers
15. Alexander Radulov RW – Nashville Predators
16. Petteri Nokelainen C – New York Islanders
17. Marek Schwarz G – St. Louis Blues
18. Kyle Chipchura C – Montreal Canadians
19. Lauri Korpikoski C – New York Rangers
20. Travis Zajac C – New Jersey Devils
21. Wojtek Wolski LW – Colorado Avalanche
22. Lukas Kaspar RW – San Jose Sharks
23. Andrej Meszaros D – Ottawa Senators
24. Kris Chucko LW – Calgary Flames
25. Rob Schremp C – Edmonton Oilers
26. Cory Schneider G – Vancouver Canucks
27. Jeff Schultz D – Washington Capitals
28. Mark Fistric D – Dallas Stars
29. Mike Green D – Washington Capitals
30. Andy Rogers D – Tampa Bay Lightning
The highlighted players are current NHL players who are consistently part of their current team (not necessarily the team that drafted them). A caveat here: drafting 18-year-old boys is not an easy job even for scouts who have done it for years on end, regardless of the team and year, mistakes happen from time to time. What I’m looking to show here is what continues to hold the CBJ from making the step to Perennial Playoff Contender, and eventually to maybe even a Cup Contender. Take a look at CBJ picks from throughout the entire draft:
2nd Round: Adam Pineault – Last seen: currently with Pardubice HC/Czech
2nd Round: Kyle Wharton – Last seen: 08-09 with Syracuse Crunch/AHL
3rd Round: Daniel Lacosta – Last seen: currently with Syracuse Crunch/AHL
3rd Round: Andrey Plekhanov – Last seen: currently with Moscow Dynamo/KHL
5th Round: Petr Pohl – Last seen: currently with SaiPa Lappeenranta/FNL
6th Round: Rob Page – Last seen: 08-09 with Trenton Devils/ECHL
6th Round: Lennart Petrell – Last seen: currently with HIFK Helsinki/FNL
7th Round: Justin Vienneau – Last seen: 06-07 season with Rouyn-Noranda Huskies/QMJHL
8th Round: Brian McGuirk – Last seen: Currently with Kalamazoo Wings/ECHL
8th Round: Matt Greer – Last seen: 08-09 Minnesota-Duluth/NCAA
9th Round: Grant Clitsome – Last seen: Currently with Syracuse Crunch/AHL

Nothing much coming from this draft class. We have only recently been able to see 9th rounder Grant Clitsome for the first time. Clitsome played four years with Clarkson University before joining the Crunch. Only time will tell what we can expect from Clitsome, or even if he will be qualified at season’s end as he is a pending RFA.

While no one will forget the two massive wins that Dan Lacosta helped back-stop the Blue Jackets to during the run to the playoffs last season, it is more and more apparent that he is not going to be a factor in the long-term plans of the franchise. His “talent analysis” from Hockey’s Future doesn’t sound good:
At 6’3, LaCosta is a tall goalie. He relies on his positioning to make the save, and needs some work with rebound control and must give up fewer bad goals. Controlling rebounds has been a problem for him, and he also needs to improve his lateral movement and ability to recover after going down to stop shots. Mentally, LaCosta will need to develop significantly.
His playing time in Syracuse has seen a dip this season, only 25 games played versus Lalande’s 41 so far. In the previous season Lacosta played 45 games. Obviously the Blue Jackets are trying to see what they have coming in the way of goaltending prospects, who in my opinion are fighting to replace Garon as the back-up goalie in a couple years.
The rest of the 2004 Entry Draft included some notable players:
Round 2: Dave Bolland (Chicago), David Booth (Florida), Brandon Dubinsky (New York Rangers), Alex Goligoski (Pittsburgh)
Round 3: Brandon Prust (Calgary), Andrej Sekera (Buffalo), Thomas Greiss (San Jose), Johan Franzen (Detroit), Dustin Boyd (Calgary
Round 4: Tyler Kennedy (Pittsburgh), Kevin Porter (Phoenix), Ryan Callahan (New York Rangers)
Round 5: Kris Versteeg (Boston), Roman Wick (Ottawa)
Round 6: Adam Pardy (Calgary), Aaron Boogaard (Minnesota), Mike Santorelli (Nashville), Roman Polak (St. Louis)
Round 7: Chad Kolarik (Phoenix), Troy Brouwer (Chicago), Matt Hunwick (Boston), Chris Campoli (New York Islanders)
Round 8: Brandon Yip (Colorado), Pekka Rinne (Nashville)
Round 9: Mark Streit (New York Islanders)
I would eventually like to spend time “analyzing” the Blue Jackets past draft classes, but it can be a very subjective topic to discuss mostly because of the underlying question, “What determines success?” Being able to contribute to the “parent club”, or being traded for necessary assets would in my mind be considered a good pick that did its job. On the flip side, never playing for the parent club, not being signed at all, or never coming from overseas should be looked at as a failure.
I have no frame of reference for how this compares to other NHL clubs draft classes from the same year, but the departure of Picard after little to no contributions to the Blue Jackets spurred me to try to take a deeper look into the failure of this specific class for the franchise.
Stats and information courtesy of Hockey’s Future, the Internet Hockey Database, and BlueJackets.com